English 125: Introduction to Literature (ACI11132A)
A Worn Path vs. Used to Live Here Once
The short stories “A Worn Path” by Eudora Welty and “Used to Live Here “Once” by Jean Rhys. In both writings the authors used people, places and things to symbolize something extra, expanding the stories into more than just what is read. I chose these stories because they both consist of strong symbolic references to life. Each story was written in a third-person point of view and consisted of a journey made by the main characters, which in both cases happened to be a black woman. Although in one story the character was already dead and in the other, fighting death, there are many similarities between the stories told. Both carry the theme, symbolism of a journey made by the main characters, which in both cases happened to be a black woman. Although in one story the character was already dead and in the other, fighting death, there are many similarities between the stories told.
In A Worn Path, Phoenix Jackson is an elderly woman that encroaches on what appears to be a physically demanding trek through the forest. Already, the symbolism begins with the name of the woman. A phoenix is a mythical Egyptian bird symbolizing immortality and resurrection that rises from its own ashes and creates another phoenix (N. Isaacs, 1963), away, the reader is made aware that Phoenix’s character is a fighter. It becomes more apparent throughout the story symbolizing the perseverance of life.
The elderly women willpower was so strong she refuses to give in to death because she knew what she had to do so her grandson could live a long her journey, she reaches a hill and she says, “Something always take a hold of me on this hill– pleads I should stay,” (Journey Into Literature, R.W. Clugston, 2010). I believe it is suggested at this point that she questions her strength to press on, not only against the hill but also against death. Her decision to accept this challenge shows her strength and determination live on her journey, she at Her judgment to accept this challenge shows her power and willpower to live on.
Once Phoenix had made it “up through pines,” she then faced the challenge of, “down through oaks” (R.W. Clugston, 2010), in which time a bush snagged the dress she had worn. This could be indicative of a problem or deterrent that any person could face during their lifetime, a sort of hitch in arrangements that gets in the way of where we are going. It is about the way in which we handle these feelings of mild anger and impatience and press on. The question that arises at this point is whether or not the elderly woman will have the might to carry on. She mentions that she was deceived by the thorny bush and had thought that it was just a “pretty little green bush,” (R.W. Clugston, 2010). This may symbolize the trials that people face in life. Sometimes things appear at first to be one thing, when in fact the outcome is unpredicted. However distracting, Phoenix manages to become free of the bush, and without damaging her dress in the process. I found this is a remarkable detail because while she could have just ripped herself free of the bush, she took the time and showed staying powerful in making sure the thorns would not leave their mark on her clothes. This seems to be an indication to her age and knowledge. With such a big mission ahead of her, the time she took to spare her clothes entail that she is elderly and not quick to make rash decisions.
There is also a strong indication to Christmas all throughout the story of Phoenix’s journey. The colors green and red appear many times starting with the description of the elderly woman’s hair which was tied with a red rag, her travelling through pinewoods which are green and also used as Christmas trees, she comes across mistletoe after conquering the hill and upon arriving in town she sees someone carrying presents wrapped in green, red and silver. Christmas is a holiday that everyone knows of. Most recognize the Christmas season to be cheerful and one in which gift giving is a popular tradition. We do know that Phoenix was on her way to town to pick up medicine for her grandson and received a small monetary gift and used to purchase her grandson a small present. The giving of a gift that was used to purchase another is a generous symbol of what Christmas represents and was strongly displayed here.
In Used to Live Here Once, the main character that is unnamed travels a journey similar to that of Phoenix Jackson. This woman too is African American and seems to be elderly based upon the way she reflects on her surroundings and also how she views children. The events that occur in this story seem to symbolize one’s life path and the decisions that may have been made throughout the course.
The first obstacle that the woman faces is using stones to cross a river. She recalls the stepping-stones fondly and this is the first time you sense that she, like Phoenix, is familiar with the path that she has chosen. “She was standing by the river looking at the stepping stones and remembering each one.” As she remembers the stones, it seems that each one may have represented a point in her lifetime. For example, I feel that the “…safe stone where you could stand and look around,” may have represented childhood (R.W. Clugston, 2010). A safe place where you have not much responsibility and can take be a bystander until, you eventually grown up and have to make decisions for yourself.
The author describes the day as, “a fine day, a blue day,” and the sky as having a, “glassy look that she couldn’t remember” (R.W. Clugston, 2010). The color blue symbolizes peacefulness and I believe this is what the main character was feeling while dazzling on her life. Then, in the next line it is mentioned that the sky looks glassy and that she didn’t remember the sky appearing this way. I think that the symbolism here is that the sky is actually taking place of a mirror. The main character does not realize it yet, but she is actually from beyond this world and dazzling from the dead. She is revisiting her life through this journey and because it is her first time doing so, the “glassy” look was unknown.
Next, the woman comes across a familiar spot, “She turned the corner, saw that what had been the old pave had been taken up, and there too the road was much wider, but it had the same incomplete look” (R.W. Clugston, 2010). The thought that I am left with by the author’s careful placement of this memorable place missing something so powerful is unexplained it appears that the woman knew the exact spot in which the pave was placed before it was gone. Her experience leads me to believe that this represented something of high importance in her life and now it is no longer there. I do wonder why the author did not spend more time with the description of item or even suggested its significance. I suppose, however that the anxiety is what the author had hoped for. Maybe the woman had lost someone close to her; a child, bother, sister, husband, mother or father and as she walks down this memorable path she is remembering him or her. Whatever the real mystery is, I believe that this single event signify something of high importance.
As the woman reaches her destination of a house that she remembers fondly, “She stopped and looked towards the house that had been added to and also painted white” (R.W. Clugston, 2010). The additions made to the house seem to represent the thought that life moves on after death. She remembered the house one way and while it remained the same house, it had been built on to. Although she had passed on, things continued to change and evolve without her. Her indication that the house had been painted white seems racial. While it is not said that the character is in fact a black woman, it is suggested by the way she describes the children that she sees playing in the yard, “Very fair children, as Europeans in the West Indies so often are: as if the white blood is asserting itself against all odds” (R.W. Clugston, 2010). So the thought that the color of the house represents the color of people is possible, that her self and her black family had moved on and now a white family occupied the house.
While both stories tell a utterly different story, each carried heavy symbolism towards the thought of life and how each and every person may construe life in their own way. One story was told through a living woman fighting death while the other was told of a woman who was already dead. Both stories however portray life struggle as well as life joys. The women in both writings seemed to have optimistic attitude and a mature thought process. I believe that the similarities in the delivery of these stories are inspirational
Because of the upbeat outlook on life Even in the trials faced by Phoenix while travelling to town, and the unnamed woman’s confusion with memorable things that seemed out of place; both stories were uplifting and in my opinion, encouraging pieces. and that both women had a strong willpower to move on and that age or not been able to move fast didn’t stop Phoenix from doing what she need to do for her grandson and she had a strong willpower because she knew that he needed his medication so that he could live so she was determine that she would get were she needed to be, the other woman had a strong memories of what was there before she knew that some things was very different from when she live there. She knew the road had gotten wider and that it was incomplete and all the different shaped stones flat, round, pointed and the self stone I think they all had a meaning for her in some type of way.
While both stories tell a utterly different story. These two Story was alike because they both had an female African American main characters. Both story also the main character crossing a river. They both symbolized how they lived life in their own special way. The main character in these two passages had struggle but both of their lives was filled with joy. Both passages had inspirational similarities both story were uplifting and encouraging pieces. One story was told by a living women the other was told by a women that was dead. one story was told on a sunny day the other on a cold winter day.
These passages are different because one character was alive and one was deceased and one was going through the struggle the other had all read been through the struggle. The passage “ Used to Live Here Once” that took place in the main character house were she use to live and the story “A Worn Path” took place on a hill. In the “A Worn Path” the narrator name was mentioned and in “Used to Liver Here Once” her name was not mentioned in the story. In the story “A Worn Path” gives a numerous amount of details about the main character and the other passage didn’t give many. In the passage “Used to Live Here Once” talk to children without a response but in the other passage she spoke with an old man that she offered money to.” A Worn Path” is a touching story of will power. The relevant story of love and perseverance transcends a deeper message relating to death and rebirth. Welty weaves in allusions such as the myth of the phoenix, slavery, and Hercules to convey her story of Old Phoenix’s journey of death and rebirth.
Welty’s theme of death and rebirth can also be portrayed through the twelve labors of Hercules. He was sentenced to do twelve labors by another Greek god in order to obtain his freedom again. Life is a pathway we all must journey. Just like in the story, we come across many obstacles in the way that may throw us out of control or even make us lose courage. It those difficult moments, we need miracles to restore what has been damaged such as relationships, career, financial stability or health. What can these miracles be? They can be love for people around, dedication to achieve goals, prayer to God who will give us hope, and wits to make the right decisions. We need people like Phoenix whose name symbolizes a bird that had lived for five hundred years, bringing people good news and hope for happiness, hope for miracles and a better future.
Clugston, R. W. (2010). Journey into literature. San Diego, California:
Bridgepoint Education, Inc
Isaacs, N (1963). Life of Phoenix Sewance Review, 71
Ashford Online Library
Place an Order